ATF Seizes Firearms From Amish Dairy Farmer

An Amish dairyman living in Pennsylvania had his firearms seized by the ATF as part of an investigation. Here is what we know so far about this “gun bust.”



ATF Raids Cattail Foundry —

According to the Lancaster Online website, on January 12th, the ATF seized firearms from “Cattail Foundry,” a farm operated by Reuben King. The investigation involves King, who they accused of illegal firearm sales.

King admits he sold firearms but denies breaking any laws. He said:

I’m not going to deny that I was selling some.

The ATF licenses firearms dealers. The law requires that dealers follow laws and regulations in selling firearms.

King said that all the guns he owns or has sold are part of his personal collection. While he admitted he had sold guns, King says he is not a dealer.

Is Reuben King a Gun Dealer —

The ATF apparently believes King is a dealer, although the definition of a dealer is somewhat subjective. It is a practice that unless someone is engaged in repetitive buying and selling guns, they are not considered a firearms dealer. Other factors would also go into determining if someone was considered a dealer. Some indications of a dealer could be, keeping a private collection of firearms separate from others or displaying or advertising firearms for sale.

Among a slew of other regulations, dealers must conduct background checks for all firearm sales and see that the buyer has a photo identification.

King denies being a dealer and said:

This is my business, I’m a dairyman.

I was not dealing in handguns, positively not.

King said he never advertised gun sales and only sold guns from his private collection to other Amish people who wanted them for hunting. Interestingly, the Amish abstain from being photographed and thus would not have photo identification. They would not, therefore, be able to purchase a firearm from an FFL.

amish ATF

Is Reuben King a Private Seller —

If King is not a dealer, he is not subject to the exact requirements as an FFL.

Furthermore, like other states, Pennsylvania allows private parties (those who are not dealers) to sell firearms without a background check. This rule applies only to long guns, anything over 15″. Transferring handguns must go through an FFL. Additionally, the person selling the gun must not know that the buyer is prohibited.

If what King said is accurate, and he wasn’t routinely selling guns, and the guns he sold were long guns to people he did not know were prohibited, he didn’t violate any laws.

Of course, I don’t know anything more than what the news reported. It’s always possible King was selling more guns than Obama and Biden did during Fast and Furious.

It seems that King has earned special attention from the ATF. In states where it is legal to sell guns privately, make sure you’re following the law, so you don’t get caught in some mess like the one Reuben King finds himself in.

We spent a lot of time creating the best legal resource that you can use to determine any state’s firearm laws, and much, much more. Our App called Concealed Carry Gun Tools is completely free and provides legal information for every state and DC.

The free app is available for Android and iPhone.


  1. Slacker06 on February 22, 2023 at 10:45 am

    One would think the AFT could do better service to stand along the southern border and arrest true arms dealers coming across connected to the drug cartels. But alas, our government is picking on law-abiding citizens instead. Hey, lets go after the low hanging fruit. Lets go after the Catholics that prefer the Latin Mass. Lets go after parents that pay the taxes to support any given school when they protest immorality in their school’s library. Lets go after an Amish farmer who sells a few guns out of his personal collection to friends or neighbors that want a hunting rifle since they cannot go to a FFL because they have no photo ID. Isn’t;t that religious discrimination according to the law by the federal government??

  2. David C Reed on March 9, 2023 at 9:39 pm

    give the man his guns back he did not do anything wrong. ATF think they are above the law 🤔 they see all those guns or collections let’s take them all and make this man an example. So he sells guns to family and some friends it’s not against the law. people sell their guns all the time. people that have one or people that have twenty or a collector that has 500 or more people sell guns all the time. This is not a gun shop who sells new guns and they have to do back round checks. I used to have 12 guns at one time I’m down to 2 now I didn’t give them away maybe you want to come after me. Whether you have 2 guns or 500 guns or more you have no right to take his guns. Now if ATF plans on keeping the guns they basically stole from the man then they should pay him him for what each gun costs. ATF was wrong for what they did

Leave a Comment